My husband and I just had an interesting conversation in light of the most recent recall of more than 9 million hazardous toys from China. We were talking about how, as consumers, we may be partially to blame.
My husband and I *try* to live by the philosophy of quality vs. quantity, although we are no strangers to appeasing our three children with cheap plastic toys from The Dollar Store when parental judgment lapses momentarily. It’s an inexpensive slice of satisfaction.
As a people, however, we tend to overlook real value and choose what’s cheap. We are bargain shoppers, whether it is for clothes or food or services, yet we expect quality goods at an affordable price. We put the pressure on retailers such as Target and Wal-Mart to sell inexpensive toys for our children and they, in turn, tighten the noose on toy companies to line their store shelves. It’s only logical that Mattel would turn to what’s been called “America’s Toy Chest,” China, to manufacture these “quality” toys at rock-bottom prices.
Mattel, of course, is pointing the finger at China, and rightly so. Mattel claims that a subcontractor with the company that produced the lead-paint tainted toys violated an agreement to use a specific type of paint. Evidently, the subcontractor went out and purchased its own paint for, what I imagine, less money. This latest recall makes the seventh since March 2007.
Not only was our son told that he would have to give up some of his beloved Thomas trains, our daughter has now been asked to hand over her magnetic Polly Pockets, the latest, of which, she received less than a month ago as a birthday gift.
You gotta love China!
Apparently, the problem could worsen as China continues to grow in exports and their safety measures become less stringent as a result.
Less stringent? Aren’t they less stringent now?
Did you know that the United States relies on China to supply about 80% of its toys? Yikes!
I have just one thing to say to China: Thanks, but no thanks. We’ll find our toys elsewhere.
Click here to visit the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission .

16 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 14, 2007 at 7:31 pm
Nikki
My husband and I have been talking about this topic recently. We have a 2 year old and have been concerned with the recalls of so many toys. In the last one, one of his toys was on the list but it was not purchased during the time frame listed meaning it is not affected. But does that really mean it is safe? We are going to be more observant about where are son’s toys are being manufactured.
August 14, 2007 at 7:59 pm
Lance
Amen to that!
August 14, 2007 at 10:12 pm
cryitout
My brother lives in Beijing and told me the story of a dim sum place that made its shrimp filling entirely out of newspaper — yum! I looked around our toy bin for all the toys made in China. There were too many to clean out. Yikes. From now on, I’m letting my daughter play with nails or glass or razors — something safe.
Mike
August 14, 2007 at 10:44 pm
pickel
I have a great list of lead free toys on my site.
http://adopttwoboys.blogspot.com
August 15, 2007 at 12:53 am
Kathleen
I think I read somewhere that Wal-Mart ranked among the top three countries that traded with China. Now- last time I checked Wal-Mart wasn’t a country but if they are doing that much business is China, just imagine how much of our hard earned $$$ is going there. It’s quite a sad thought really.
August 15, 2007 at 2:30 am
Lor
Isn’t it just frightening that we let our children play with these toys thinking that they are perfectly safe. We have one of the recalled toys which my son loves - not looking forward to taking it off him!
August 15, 2007 at 7:49 am
danroy
You said it ” the consumer wants to buy for the cheapest price ” so the likes of Walmart etc. have their products made in China. They decide on the the price they will pay the manufacturer, often so low that it becomes impossible for the manufacturer in China to make a “decent, reasonable profit”, so the manufacturer revert to cutting costs in material quality.End result… a substandard product..
You are only seeing the tip of the iceberg!!
There will be many,many more product recalls.
Everyone loses. as the factory workers are paid meager wages, the enviroment is polluted, more unnecessary products are made.. the list goes on and on..
Dave
August 15, 2007 at 11:05 am
Monica
I was thinking about this the other day and wondered if some of the manufacturing of things would come back to the U.S. over time, so that quality control and the like would be better.
August 15, 2007 at 11:45 am
Jen
Amazing huh? And to think these toys have been around around for months and now are being recalled. It’s freaky how this is happening and whats more is how the head guy committed suicide from this happening.
August 15, 2007 at 12:49 pm
Amber
The extent of this recall is pretty alarming. But I had no idea of the percentages!
August 15, 2007 at 2:59 pm
Melissa
This whole situation has definitely made me rethink what we are buying!
August 15, 2007 at 8:41 pm
Sonya
I have to take away his toys the 3rd time. Yikes!
August 18, 2007 at 8:49 am
Laura
Have you seen Mommy Zabs new website? I think it’s called notchinamade.net.
Anyway, her whole website is about problems with products from China.
August 19, 2007 at 5:08 pm
And Miles To Go....
It is really hard to find a toy not made in China. Some companies that say their toys are made in the USA, if you do some looking into it may be assembled in the USA but the parts are still made in China. When I was in China last year, I saw no toys with Mattel or brands we are used to in the US, I believe most of them are exported to other countries. I don’t think that things will get worse, I really think they will get better, it being a wake up call for more China standards. We are dealing with an entirely different political system over there and different living standards which plays a lot into this whole issue. But I don’t think that the US will shut down relations to China due to this carelessness because we rely heavily on CHINA for MANY THINGS other than toys.
August 24, 2007 at 9:57 am
Erin
I’ve been thinking about this lately too. It’s insane. My oldest is 9 so we have YEARS of toys in our house. Do I need to go back and test all of them for lead? Maybe there are some that missed being recalled, or I missed hearing the recall (even though I’m pretty good about checking).
toys from China are cheap, and finding ones that aren’t made there will take more work. But worth it for the safety of our kids.
August 26, 2007 at 3:48 pm
Mira
I find this whole subject so upsetting, as do many. What I find even more upsetting is the fact that American food companies, such as Hershey, are contracting with China to build plants to manufacture. Bleah! We’ve also discovered that it’s REALLY hard to know what is and isn’t safe and to buy toys/clothes/etc not made in China.