
I have a friend whose daughter is eight months older than is my Hannah. Not long after her redheaded beauty turned six, she came to me feeling a wee bit perplexed; she wanted to know where her sweet little girl had gone. Apparently, her ooey-gooey sweet disposition had turned into nothing but sass and attitude. I found my friend’s claims a little difficult to believe, considering her daughter had never been anything but pleasant in my company, and I remember laughing off the conversation with a wave of the hand. Later on, however, I couldn’t help but wonder if I might suffer the same angst with my own offspring.
The answer, of course, was yes. My heart has been wrenched and torn incessantly since the day Hannah blew out those six candles with one big breath. In fact, I am convinced her birthday wish was to find a way to send me to Hell as quickly as possible on a bumpy road paved with tears and strife. Moreover, if I happened to score a few wrinkles and gray hairs along the way, all the better.
Hannah is now eight, and lately my mind has been wandering back to when times with my daughter were uncomplicated. Certainly, she is a fascinating and lovely individual at age eight, all gangly limbs and freckled cheeks and crooked teeth. She is gorgeous on the outside, but more important to me is how beautiful she is on the inside. She is a true friend – never one to judge and always the one to stick up for the underdog.
After reflecting on my feelings, I came to the realization that Hannah is the same wonderful person she has always been despite how she continues to physically change and grow emotionally. Unfortunately, I haven’t been keeping pace. I’ve been stuck in the past, trying to pull the reigns on a little girl who’s not quite so little anymore. As a woman responsible for “growing” another woman, I now understand that it’s not my right to control my daughter and make her bend to my will.
We bring our infants home from the hospital secure in the knowledge that we are the ones in control, the parents who know what’s best. Time goes on, however, and little darling begins to express her likes and dislikes, whether it be for a particular sippy cup or tub toy. She grows a little older yet, and all of a sudden, she’s refusing to wear clothes, preferring, instead, to walk around naked and leave warm puddles throughout the house like an untrained puppy dog. This is hard, you say, to everyone who will listen or to yourself when no one is around. She’s so stubborn. She’s so defiant. Why won’t she just listen?
I have to admit that Hannah was the model child. She was easy on every level, and I can honestly say I can look back on years one through five without any complaints or parental regret. *For those of you rolling your eyes, rest assured that parenthood, in general, hasn’t been a total cakewalk for me. My son was born when Hannah was just twenty-seven months old, and those of you who know what raising a child with behavioral difficulties and autism-like tendencies is like will know that most days are a struggle. Throw into the mix another toddler who is mischief personified, and you have one heck of a party!*
There came a time, however, when I could no longer tell Hannah to do something and expect her to do it without question. This wasn’t just a bit of toddler-defiance; this was full-fledge questioning-of-authority in which I had to justify myself to her. At first, I was taken aback. Imagine, having to answer to a child!
The concept is difficult, especially for a person who craves order and likes to be the one in control. Not too long ago, however, I took a long look at my daughter and realized, perhaps for the first time, that she is a real person and not some miniature caricature of me. The same can be said for all my children, and I feel it’s hardly fair to shackle them with my beliefs and wishes. *over inconsequential matters*
Lest you assume I run a house devoid of discipline, that is hardly the case. I’ve learned, however, that there can be absolutely no control where there is no respect. I’ve realized that it’s not my children who need to learn to respect me, but it’s me who needs to earn their respect.
**The above photo was taken on a day, not too long ago, when I forgot what respect looks like. Being the beautiful person she is, and certainly the more righteous, my daughter left me a peace offering.**

11 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 16, 2007 at 10:12 pm
kristi
Beautiful post about raising your daughter. I must remember, when the time comes, that my own daughter is simply not a “mini-me” but that she has her own interests, wishes, and desires.
August 17, 2007 at 8:35 am
Family Man in the City
Thank you for a wonderful post hitting on a topic too many parents are unaware of. While most parents have some concept of developmental milestones for very young children*, they seem to not understand that there are similar milestones well beyond the toddler years. A defiant six-year-old, while challenging, is not at all unusual.
In my years as a parent educator, I have worked with far too many parents who were sure something was horribly wrong when their two-year-old refused to share toys. Many, though, realize this is quite common (though they still appreciate tips on dealing with it!). In groups of parents of teens, though, there is often strong resistance to the idea that there are behaviors common enough to be seen as expectations.
While a late-preschooler’s defiance and a late-preteen’s seeming abandonment of family identity are no less common than a three-year-old who suddenly seems to reject all food, parents of the three-year-old are usually more easily calmed.
Thanks for the reminder that parenting is not only the most important job any of us will ever have, it is also one of the few we are expected to perform without any training.
(*Some, of course, are TOO aware and assume any variation is a serious problem…
August 17, 2007 at 9:48 am
Melissa
What a wonderful post! I was caught off guard when Dominic hit late 5’s and now - I didn’t expect the sass. I love that you worded it as you not keeping pace…a good way for me to think of it when I’m frustrated.
August 17, 2007 at 10:15 am
Tiffany
So - you are telling me that once we et past these oh so wonderful terrible 2’s I will have to deal with a terrible 6 year old!! Can I have my one year old back - that was a great age!!
August 17, 2007 at 11:31 am
Family Man in the City
Actually, Tiffany, that one-year-old “was a great age” points to one of two weaknesses of “Ages and Stages”:
nobody (and I do me NObody) is ever completely prepared for parenthood or knew exactly what to expect.
1) “Age appropriate behaviors” are an ala carte menu with numerous “chef’s specials” that aren’t listed. Your one-year old may have “chosen” a set of behaviors that was different than most. Two kids of the same age can be wildly different while still being “age appropriate”. (Various parents will tell you that child #2 was MUCH easier or harder in various ways than child #1.)
2) Though the child “orders” from the menu of behaviors, you might or might not like her/his choices. An appropriate behavior one parent finds exhausting, irritating or confusing another may find energizing, endearing or enlightening. Thus Mom and Dad may disagree about which behaviors need what kind of response. Also (as I’m sure you’ve already noticed…
Long story short (too late!): Your expectations based on your neighbor’s/friend’s/coworker’s/favorite author’s description of parenthood does not match your actual experience because you are not your neighbor/friend/coworker/favorite author* and your child is not their child**.
*Yeah, you could be your own favorite author, but that’s not what I meant. And people like that shouldn’t be raising kids…
**Unless you are partnered with your n/f/c/fa, then their child and your child might be one and the same***, but that’s not what I mean either.
***Hopefully, you won’t need a paternity test to find out****.
****Hopefully, if you DO need a paternity test, you won’t need to go on a daytime talkshow to get the paternity test*****.
*****Hopefully, if you DO go on a daytime talkshow for the paternity test, you’ll let us all know so we can be sure to TiVO it (especially if it involves your favorite author).
August 17, 2007 at 12:21 pm
Gnorb
Lest you assume I run a house devoid of discipline, that is hardly the case. I’ve learned, however, that there can be absolutely no control where there is no respect. I’ve realized that it’s not my children who need to learn to respect me, but it’s me who needs to earn their respect.
Remember, when all else fails, a belt to the ass works wonder.
In all seriousocity, what you describe here isn’t just for kids, but for adults also. John Maxwell talks about the positional and inspirational leaders, where the positional is one who demands respect (and a following) due to their position, and the inspirational is one whose actions make others want to respect and follow them. He also talks about how an organization will reflect half the strength of the leader but twice the faults, so when you say,
“…that she is a real person and not some miniature caricature of me. The same can be said for all my children…”
Remember that’s something to be thankful for. Annoying and painful, yes. But then again growth always is.
Congrats. Sounds like you’re on the way to becoming not just a good mother, but also a good leader to your kids.
August 17, 2007 at 12:46 pm
Lady
I’m 21. My problem is one that teenagers have–my grandmother, whom mostly raised me, still treats me like I’m five.
So, were as most parents forget what it was like for them, I still feel it. My grandmother is a sweet and caring individual, but I think that she simply forgot that not all of her “children” are going to stay around her forever. (My mother still lives at home with her.) She seems to have missed out on the good parts of my life when I was a teen because of this. But, I lost out on a lot too.
My fiancee and I are currenly trying to have a baby. I don’t know if I’m pregnant or not yet (hope!), but whatever the case may be, I’m ready for it. *Well, as ready as one can be!* I know what mistakes both my mother and grandmother made with me, and I hope to have learned much from them.
Even though I know my children will grow up and I’m not going to want them to, especially when they hit that defiant stage, I’ll try and remember how hard growing up was for me when I lacked the support and backing of my family. I don’t want to let my children down in the areas where I was, and I want to be there for them when they need me, but not shelter them from the world I’m terrified will take them from me.
I just hope I can be the best parent I can and I know that’s what most people strive for. If you understand that your precious little girl isn’t always going to agree or turn to you, then your two steps ahead of her. Because when she does need you (and as a teenager she will), you’ll be there with open arms.
August 17, 2007 at 3:05 pm
narziss
nice post!
August 17, 2007 at 5:11 pm
Mary Beth
I too am raising 2 girls and a boy. I am pretty demanding about manners and respect. In fact these little cherubs when being disciplined must answer me with “yes Ma’am” and my husband with “yes Sir” EVEN the 3 year old. They are not allowed to call adults by their first names unless it is preceded by a Miss or Mr. (for example my best friend is Miss Michelle) I am aware they will go through all kinds of different and appropriate stages in their lives but the manner in which they express their frustration is not always acceptable. All people must be treated with respect and courtesy especially family members not just friends. As my Dad said to me “If you are mean and spiteful to your family, not another of your friends will ever darken this door until you straighten up.”
I think that is one of the best rules he ever gave us. Of course not all 3 children are disciplined in the same way, I am not running a democracy. I tend to discipline each child specifically according to what works best for them. I am very lucky in that the two oldest are pretty spontaneous aplogizers. Kevin’s ADD makes things challenging in the area of homework but believe it or not he is usually better behaved than his older sister! One thing that I believe limits the sass from developing quite as soon is not letting them ride the school bus. I believe the bus is one place where kids are extremely unsupervised and they learn a lot of things from older kids. We are so lucky we can walk to our school. I remember so much bullying done on the bus and very little was ever done as kids were to scared to report bullying and even if they did who was going to change that environment? The driver has his/her hands full just driving. Well sorry so long winded. From everything you write Hannah sounds like a little gem.
August 18, 2007 at 9:49 am
Nadine
You write so well. Excellent post. I like your new digs. It’s always hard to switch over to a new blog and keep it up at the same time. Nice job. Have a great weekend.
August 20, 2007 at 12:58 am
Courtney
This was an incredible post. I’m so glad I followed Laura’s recommendatio from her Writing Thoughts blog. It brought tears to my eyes. I have a 2 year old and 5 month old (27 months apart no less!) and reading this post reminded me of how fleeting these years are and how soon I’ll be facing a 6 and 8 year old.